Ofsted chief wants inspection to feel like ‘peer review system’

Inspection should be 'of the system, by the system, for children and parents', says Sir Martyn Oliver

Inspection should be 'of the system, by the system, for children and parents', says Sir Martyn Oliver

Sir Martyn Oliver

Sir Martyn Oliver has said he wants Ofsted inspection to feel like a “peer-review system”.

At the Schools and Academies Show today, the chief inspector discussed his ongoing “Big Listen” consultation, launched following the inquest into the death of headteacher Ruth Perry.

Speaking at the London event, Oliver said Ofsted had embarked on a “reform journey” and there was a “lot more to come”.

Sir Martin Oliver

But stressed he was a civil servant, and the watchdog has to follow government policy set by ministers.

A coroner ruled in December that an Ofsted inspection at Caversham Primary School contributed to Perry’s suicide.

Today, Oliver reiterated that when he took on the job in January, he “wanted Ofsted to be of the system, by the system, for children and parents”.

He stressed that the “vast majority” of its workforce were serving practitioners such as heads, deputy heads and college principals, and that he wants to “lean into that”.

Oliver said he wanted it to feel like “in some ways, it’s the professional inspectorate, which is a peer-review system”.

Heads have pushed for peer review

Leaders have been pushing for a system of peer review to replace high-stakes inspections for some time.

Earlier this year, a paper by the NAHT heads’ union said the “potential should be explored for a low-stakes inspection model, where regular inspection is conducted by HMI working in local patches or areas”.

“This could offer impactful diagnostic insight, take account of local context and challenge, and promote collaboration, peer review and area-wide school improvement,” the paper said.

A survey by the ASCL union in 2020 on ‘improving Ofsted inspections previously revealed some school leaders were keen on a peer review-style system.

The survey’ in February 2020, which had 793 respondents, found some “would like to see the involvement of more serving leaders on inspection teams or the replacement of Ofsted with a more collaborative peer review system,” the union noted at the time.

‘Funding has dropped’

Oliver’s comments echoed remarks made to Schools Week in January, when he called for “a long-term response that actually sees Ofsted being far more a part of the system”.

“It really shouldn’t be a sense of duality or elimination, it should be synthesis. And that’s what I’m trying to create: it’s not us and them, or get rid of one or keep the other. It should be Ofsted is ‘of’ the system, ‘by’ the system and ‘for’ children, parents and students,” he added at the time.

Speaking today, Oliver also highlighted that since 2005 Ofsted’s “remit has grown and grown but since 2009-10 our funding has dropped in real terms by 29 per cent”.

Ofsted said in its response to a committee report on inspection that delivering more in-depth inspections called-for by MPs would cost £8.5 million a year, and warned declining inspector pay means they are losing staff to academy trusts.

Oliver said today that money “clearly has an impact”, but said he did not think Ofsted should “be at the front of the line” for more funding.

More from this theme


NAHT votes to explore ‘legal and industrial routes’ to secure Ofsted reform

Government 'under notice' that action could follow if heads don't get 'meaningful answers'

Freddie Whittaker

Schools ‘putting off’ SEND pupils face more Ofsted scrutiny

Watchdog gathers 'insights' from councils and checks if schools look 'out of kilter' with their area, says chief inspector

Samantha Booth

Ofsted to scrap subject deep dives for ungraded inspections

Sir Martyn Oliver says 'it isn't helpful to cram' full inspection detail into ungraded visits

Samantha Booth

Trust boss criticises Ofsted complaints transparency

CEO speaks out about how he persuaded watchdog to 'set aside' report amid inspector criticism

Freddie Whittaker

Politicians and media would ‘draw own conclusions’ if Ofsted grades scrapped – DfE

Government also rejects calls from MPs to reduce the frequency of inspections

Freddie Whittaker

School loses court battle over Ofsted downgrade to ‘good’

Thomas Telford school took watchdog to court over row about 'cooling off periods' not being registered as suspensions

Lucas Cumiskey

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

One comment

  1. Libby Patterson

    Too late. The horse has bolted. The SLT are going to be too busy actually doing some work as they hunt for staff to put in front of the students having pushed the qualified and experienced teachers out with their sociopathic micromanagement and bullying of one of the country’s greatest workforces. Oh well!